Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Tapu Misa plays victim role to hilt

Tapu Misa gets it wrong and plays the race/victim card.

She sometimes gets it right but her heritage gets in the way of reality in her latest column:

People keep telling me what a nice man John Key is. The jovial Christchurch taxi driver told me the National Party leader was the nicest politician he's ever met. Key was so casually dressed and unassuming the driver almost didn't recognise him.

The perpetually grinning Lockwood Smith seems a nice enough man, too. But his comments last week about the smallness of Asian hands and the toilet training needs of Pacific migrant workers betrayed a world view that continues to prevail in the National Party...

So it's become harder for poor kids to escape their lowly position. John Key was fortunate that he was poor before the 1980s, when we were a more equal society, and the welfare system was considerably more generous than it is today.

Government policy matters.

The policies of the 80s and 90s made New Zealand one of the most unequal countries in the OECD.

But since 2000, under Labour, that gap's been closing. Not enough, thanks to Labour's resistance to restoring benefits to pre-1991 levels, but progress.

Full Article

She jumps right on board the Labour KiwiRail train going to nowheresville.

Unfortunately Misa is lying to her readers here. John Key would be far better off today in terms of welfare than he would have been in the 1970s because New Zealand is in the grip of record welfare numbers, when Working for Families welfare and a whole host of other new welfare packages are taken into account.

Another key difference that Misa ignores completely is that because welfare wasn't seen as a right back when Key was a boy he was able to escape its evil clutches and become a successful man. 

He would have great difficulty doing that under today's conditions where Labour inspired incentives are instilled to remain on welfare instead of working hard to get off it.

Shame on Misa, she wears her "culture" like a badge but here fails to inspire only mediocrity and dependence, something that her culture is unfortunately not short on.

c Political Animal 2008


  1. FACT: The standard of living for all NZers went into it's steepest decline after the introduction of the *generous* welfare system mentioned. Since Labour has been in charge, we have slipped even further.
    The only way to get richer is to grow more wealth and then share it around. Cullen would disagree with me but money does NOT grow on trees.

  2. Agree with your first statement wholeheartedly anon.

    The second part of your argument isnt clear.

    If you mean growing wealth to "share it around" by the State using force to extract more taxes off you then I disagree strongly.

    If you mean growing wealth so others can benefit voluntarily through better jobs and more commerce then we are on the same bus.

  3. Misa is just an ignorant bitch all round. She's should count her lucky stars we are so racist. Would dumbass even have a job with the Herald if she wasn't a minority? Think about it.


Comment on Share Investor Stuff