Long Term View: Best Stocks from the Series

In the Long Term View series (see links to each individual stock at the bottom of this post) of posts I have looked at stocks listed on the NZX in relation to their returns to shareholders over the life of their listing -what shareholders would now see in their back pockets if they had invested in the company IPO. The calculation of returns included dividends and tax credits and other relevant details.

The calculation of return is based on available data and may vary from stock to stock. An absence of data usually means a better return than I have calculated will be the case.

In each individual post the differences will be pointed out.

I have been surprised by the spectacular returns from some and not so surprised by the dismal returns of others but have learnt, once again, that the best returns come from holding good stocks for a long period.

My ideas on stocks as one of the better long-term investments have been reinforced by this series.

Below are rankings in the series from number one down to the bottom in terms of annual returns. Click on company name for more detail on returns.


Long Term View Series Ranking


1. New Zealand Refining Ltd [NZR.NZ] Over 21 years of available data NZR has returned 7800%, an annual return of just over 371%.

2. Port of Tauranga Ltd [POT.NZ] Over 18 years of available data POT has returned over 1475%, an annual return of just over 81%.

3. = Ryman Healthcare Ltd [RYM.NZ] Over 11 years of available data RYM has returned over 680%, an annual return of just over 60%.

3. = Mainfreight Ltd [MFT.NZ] Over 14 years of available data MFT has returned over 830%, an annual return of just over 60%.

5. Sanford Ltd [SAN.NZ] Over 22 years of available data NZR has returned over 895%, an annual return of just over 40%.

6. Sky City Entertainment Group Ltd [SKC.NZ] Over 14 years of available data SKC has returned over 540%, an annual return of just over 38%.

7. Auckland International Airport [AIA.NZ] Over 11 years of available data AIA has returned over 400%, an annual return of just over 36%.

8. Ebos Ltd [EBO.NZ] Over 13 years of available data EBO has returned over 455%, an annual return of just over 35%.

9. Freightways Ltd [FRE.NZ] Over 6 years of available data FRE has returned over 190%, an annual return of just over 31%.

10. The Warehouse Group Ltd [WHS.NZ] Over 16 years of available data WHS has returned over 500%, an annual return of just over 30%.

11. = Telecom New Zealand Ltd [TEL.NZ] Over 18 years of available data TEL has returned over 450%, an annual return of just over 25%.

11. = Telstra Corp Ltd [TLS.NZ] Over 12 years of available data TLS has returned over 300%, an annual return of just over 25%.

13. Pumpkin Patch Ltd [PPL.NZ] Over 6 years of available data PPL has returned over 125%, an annual return of just over 20%.

14. Contact Energy Ltd [CEN.NZ] Over 11 years of available data CEN has returned over 200%, an annual return of just over 18%.

15. Sky Network Television Ltd [SKT.NZ] Over 13 years of available data SKT has returned over 215%, an annual return of just over 16%.

16. Metlifecare Ltd [MET.NZ] Over 16 years of available data MET has returned over 540%, an annual return of just under 16%.

17. Delegats Group Ltd [DGL.NZ] Over 4 years of available data DGL has returned 50% an annual return of 12.5%.

18. Fisher & Paykel Healthcare Ltd [FPH.NZ] Over 8 years of available data FPH has returned over 93%, an annual return of just over 11%.

19. = Goodman Fielder Ltd [GFF.NZ] Over 4 years of available data GFF has returned over 30%, an annual return of just under 7%.

19. = Hellaby Holdings Ltd [HBY.NZ] Over 16 years of available data HBY has returned over 30%, an annual return of just under 7%.

21. Restaurant Brands Ltd [RBD.NZ] Over 13 years of available data RBD has returned over 60%, an annual return of just under 4.5%.

22. Briscoe Group Ltd [BGR.NZ] Over 9 years of available data BGR has returned over 21%, an annual return of just over 2.33%.

23. Fisher & Paykel Appliances Ltd [FPA.NZ] Over 8 years of available data FPA has returned over 11%, an annual return of just over 1.37%.

24. Air New Zealand Ltd [AIR.NZ] Over 8 years of available data AIR has returned over 6%, an annual return of just over 0.75%.

25. AMP Ltd [AMP.NZ] Over 12 years of available data AMP has returned minus 50%, an annual return of just over minus 4%.


Disc I own AIA, BGR, FPH, FRE, GFF, MFT, PPL, RYM, SKC, WHS shares in the Share Investor Portfolio


Download Company Reports from the Long Term View series






c Share Investor 2010

John Palmer Tipples on the Shareholder

Air New Zealand Ltd [AIR.NZ] chairman John Palmer has decided to side with the politicians over the great credit card swindle of New Zealand taxpayers.

Good on him for openly declaring his indiscretions but shareholders and taxpayers shouldn't be paying for John's tipples after work.

John reckons:

mini-bar bills are "just part of commercial life".
The professional director said yesterday that he felt sorry for some MPs over criticism received for claiming expenses such as alcohol in hotel rooms.
"I've got a good deal of sympathy for some of them, as someone who travels a fair bit and who does actually have a beer out of the hotel fridge and puts it on the hotel account, and spends a huge amount of time away."
Often hotel rooms were places of work, where staff made progress on decisions with colleagues or guests, Mr Palmer said. "That's just part of commercial life." Read More at Stuff.co.nz
Mr Palmer is also a director of AMP Ltd [AMP.NZ] Rabobank in this part of the world and Chairman of State owned miner Solid Energy.
I would argue that Mr Palmer has breached a line when he considers that shareholders and or taxpayers should be footing the bill for his alcohol indulgence.
Alcohol is definitely personal spending and at minibar prices shareholders are getting an even rawer deal. Have you checked out the price of a minibar Mars Bar recently!
Am I being petty?
Maybe, but I think spending like this shows a contempt for those employing you and paying your wages and a culture of waste, especially evident at Air New Zealand and Solid Energy.
Shareholders in Air New Zealand and AMP should get in contact with the respective investor Centres and let them know they are not happy with John's free spending.
You should be annoyed with John and his attitude. It is your money that he is wasting and as shareholders and taxpayers you deserve much better.
It is indicative of further waste.
Contacts
Air NZ Investor Centre
AMP Investor Centre
Solid Energy

Recent Share Investor Reading

• The History Of: Hallenstein Glasson Holdings Ltd
• Share Investor discusses Convention Centre proposal with Sky City CEO Nigel Morrison
• Burger Fuel 2010 Full Year Profit Analysis
• Long Term View: Port Of Tauranga Ltd
• ASB Bank: Customer "Service"
• NZX's Top 10 Dividend Returns

Discuss this Topic @ Share Investor Forum

Security Analysis: Sixth Edition, Foreword by Warren Buffett (Security Analysis Prior Editions) by Benjamin Graham Buy new: $41.77 / Used from: $33.50 Usually ships in 24 hours

c Share Investor 2010

Time for Retirement?

Two new Retirement Home Village operators are going to list on the NZX in the next few months. Last week AMP announced the floating of their Retirement unit and today ING have announced that their two village's are on the block for a float to the public.

When these two operators are listed it will bring the number of listed retirement home operators to four.

These IPOs' are part of a wave of activity sweeping the retirement village sector.

CVC Partners said last month that it was looking at selling Guardian Healthcare and Goldman Sachs JBWere's private equity unit is rumoured to be looking to float, sell or raise new capital for its Vision Senior Living group.

The two IPO's also have a connection of sorts. NZ First Capital, who are floating Summerset and Forsyth Barr, who is floating ING's retirement unit, got together to float the abysmal IPO failure, Feltex, a few years ago. Reminders of overvaluations , high debt and creative accounting still resound in the investment community from that fiasco.

The ING groups' village's are by far the smallest by number of units at around 150 with only two properties, while AMPs' Summerset has 11 village's and over 1500 occupants.

ING are asking for $NZ100m while AMP are looking at 300m.

Ryman Healthcare [RYM.NZ], the biggest listed Retirement operator, has a market cap of over 1B and Metlifecare[MET.NZ]around 700m.

Ryman Healthcare has today just reiterated its profit growth for the current year at around 20%. It has been growing at this rate for many years and seems confident that it will grow at this rate for years to come.

At first glance AMP's Summerset looks like a great opportunity to get into this industry, which is growing rapidly as the population gets older. How good the offer really is will only become fully apparent as we get a look at the prospectus in a few weeks time. Until then we can reserve judgement.

On the other hand the ING offer I have some problems with. While ING is a highly reputable company, the track record of some of the participants may give cause for some restraint before plunking down your moola. Colin Reynolds was the head of the pyramid "property development" company Chase Corp which went bust in the 1980s, while Robin Congreve was involved with Fay Richwhite during the Winebox tax fiasco. Beware.

One of their villages is also 20 years old so may need some capital to fix up the paintwork and spruce up the surroundings and decor for the 21st century.

The retirement sector looks set for good growth for some years to come. With good margins and rapidly increasing and also affluent population. The baby boomers, when they do decide to relinquish their hold on the rest of us, will provide a mini-boom in this industry in 10-15 years.

The added bonus of consolidation as the players in this sector get more numerous is an added attraction. Currently the majority of retirement home living is being done by individual owners of villages, that is, operators owning just one village. Good assets are always up for sale.

Of course no investment is without risk and the retirement sector, like every other one, cannot continue to grow unabated the way it has. It will have its ups and downs.

Post prospectus of AMPs' Summerset, if the figures and management look good, I am going to buy as much as I can. If it is the golden egg that I think it is then demand is going to far outstrip supply.

Burger Fuel eat your heart out.

DISCLOSURE I own Ryman Healthcare shares

Related Share Investor Reading

Stocks on my Watchlist: Metlifecare Ltd
Why did you buy that stock? Ryman Healthcare

Related Amazon Reading


The Warren Buffett Way, Second Edition by Robert G. Hagstrom
Buy new: $9.72 / Used from: $6.67
Usually ships in 24 hours


c Share Investor 2007