Showing posts with label Labour Party Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Labour Party Policy. Show all posts

Sunday, October 30, 2011

The loop to Knowheresville

Ghost Train by ML87

Political running mates the Labour Party and Len Brown and his left wing branch of the Auckland council have colluded to fleece Aucklanders and the country at large of billions of dollars to expand 300 year old technology because they think it might work as a means of transport in the 21st century:

"If Labour was elected to government it would pay $1.2 billion or half of the cost of the proposed inner Auckland rail loop, Labour leader Phil Goff told around 100 supporters at an open air party meeting today.

The loop is projected to cost $2.4 billion.

Auckland City would have to pay half, and a Goff lead government would pay the other half by cancelling a "holiday highway" north of Auckland.

Goff said to become the world class city Auckland wants to become, it needs a world class transport system.

The current western and southern motorways were "bloody nightmares" he said.

Labour wanted to support Auckland Mayor Len Brown's plan for an inner city underground rail loop which would double the amount of trains the Britomart transport system could handle.

He attacked Transport Minister Steven Joyce, saying he was "mesmerised" by motorways and was planning to build a $1.7 billion motorway from Puhoi to Wellsford, which would link popluar beach destinations". Stuff.co.nz

The only problem with this proposal is that the 2.4 billion price tag is conservative, barely 2% of Aucklanders use trains and over the life of any proposed system the loop and its extension will lose billions more dollars that Aucklanders and Kiwis simply don't have.

Another major drawback is that motorists will be subsidizing rail through increased petrol taxes, road tolls and congestion charges.

Put simply it may have been a good idea 2 -300 years ago but technology as it is now means a rail loop and expanded rail network is expensive, uneconomic, polluting, inefficient and will not solve any current or future perceived transport problems.

Add to this that Labour want to ditch the long needed Northern motorway extension to help fund the government's share under their proposal and you clearly have a lose lose, situation.

The extension north will save lives, be a boon for trade between Northland and Auckland and the rest of the North Island and provide a much needed stimulus to a long-lagging Northland economy.

Labour want to ditch that in favour of a wet dream of train-tracks crisscrossing Auckland that will be a white elephant that ratepayers and taxpayers will be paying for dearly as long as it exists.

We need fiscal restraint at this time, not pork barrel politics and favours for mates.

Think Bigger


Darren Rickard 2011




Thursday, September 1, 2011

Labour Party Policy Analysis: Youth Employment

OK, it is a new season. Well, yes, it is the first day of Spring but it is also hunting season for dopey politicians as we are just under 3 months from the November 26 general election.



I will from today relaunch Political Animal and comment with much more frequency - as I did in 2008 - on the comings and going of those that have been brave or foolish enough to put themselves up for public office.


Unlike the previous incarnation of this blog though, I will focus mostly on party policy rather than who has slept with who, who is sticking the knife into Phil Goff or the latest nonsense that comes from the mouth of Murray McCully or Hone Harawera. I will leave that to the guys and girls at Whaleoil, Tumeke, The Standard and the other blogs that focus on Wellington rather than how these dropkicks affect the man or indeed woman on mainstreet.


I will rank the policy out of 10 in terms of its usefulness and all importantly the cost to the taxpayer.


With that bollocks over with we will start by looking at the Labour Party and the policy they released today in respect to "youth employment".

"Labour would turn dole payments into apprenticeships subsidies to tackle youth unemployment rates, leader Phil Goff said today.

Mr Goff unveiled a $251 million package aiming to leave the 24,000 currently unemployed teenagers either earning or learning within three years.

The four-year plan follows youth from school into education or the workforce.

It suggested converting dole payments into an $8700 subsidy to fund 9000 apprenticeship placements.

"Our package will convert dole payments into incentives for employers to take on additional apprentices. We will match skill training within and outside of schools with real job opportunities," he said.

The package also suggests introducing 5000 new training places for 16 and 17 year olds and 1000 new group and shared apprenticeships.

Mentors would be set up for at-risk school leavers, so they could be encouraged into a job or employment opportunities.

"We will build on proven programmes such as Gateway, the youth transition service, tertiary high schools and trades academies, and the Conservation Corps," he said.

Mr Goff said the four-year package would be paid for from revenue from Labour's proposed tax plan.

"However we will reprioritise $80 million from existing schemes, with $58 million going to the apprenticeship subsidy instead of dole payments, giving a net total cost of $171 million over four years." NZ Herald, 1 Sept 2011

All good stuff but this has been tried by Labour and other political parties before and failed. In the previous Labour Government they turned out thousands of individuals trained in much needed skills such as scuba divers and media personal just to name a few. When politicians get involved in things like this they have always failed. Training has never met demand in the market and millions have been lost in the process.

The kicker for this policy though is that it would involve borrowing at least $170 million to fund it and as we know the country really cant afford this kind of borrowing and Labour say they will pay for this eventually from new taxes that they will introduce.

Not an original idea but Labour at least are getting some policy out there instead of concentrating on rolling their leader and they should be respected for that.

Their Youth Employment policy gets a 4 out of 10 from me.

Download the full policy

Think Bigger



Darren Rickard 2011